Chunklet reports that Patton Oswalt’s comedy album Werewolves and Lollipops was not nominated for a Grammy. Neither was Maria Bamford’s How to WIN!
I’m not surprised since the Grammy isn’t an award for quality or innovation — it’s a popularity contest, or really, a familiarity contest. Who was nominated: George Lopez, Lisa Lampanelli, Steven Wright, Harry Shearer, and Flight of the Concords. Picking Steven Wright or Harry Shearer is like picking Jethro Tull for best metal band — they’re great performers, and legitimately comedic, but are they new, fresh or innovative? Probably not. Andrea Dice Lampanelli is crazy funny, but she’s so vulgar that you’ll feel like taking a shower after listening to her. George Lopez has been around for a while, but his new routines are always topical — I understand why he was nominated. Flight of the Concords is definitely funny in a Tenacious D, geeky, hipster, Williamsburg Brooklyn sort of way — their time is now, so I can see them getting a vote. All things considered I agree with Chunklet that Patton was overlooked — he’s the frickin’ Rat from Ratatouille! It’s not like he’s some obscure comedian. Ratatouille beat the Simpson’s Movie (Shearer) in theaters, didn’t it?
According to Cracked magazine, the Simpsons not only jumped the shark in the 1990s, “it ate the shark, shit the shark, and then jumped over the shit” — an unpopular view, but I agree. Funny shit, though, at times.
The A Special Thing has released their top 20 comedian’s poll for 2007:
Rank/Name/First Place Votes (in parentheses)/Total Points/Previous Rank (in black)
1. Paul F. Tompkins (17) - 524 pts. 1
2. Patton Oswalt (3) - 346 pts. 4
3. Louis CK (9) - 332 pts. 2
4. Zach Galifianakis (7) - 276 pts. 3
5. Scharpling & Wurster (10) - 211 pts. 7
6. Maria Bamford (1) - 189 pts. 6
7. Jimmy Pardo (5) - 186 pts. 5
8. Doug Benson (1) - 176 pts. 14
9. Eugene Mirman (2) - 148 pts. 9
10. Tim & Eric (4) - 145 pts. 8
11. Todd Glass (2) - 116 pts. 13
12. Andy Kindler (3) - 112 pts. 10
13. Jen Kirkman (2) - 92 pts. 11
14. Flight of the Conchords (1) - 77 pts. n/a
15. Todd Barry - 74 pts. 12
16. Brody Stevens (1) - 68 pts. n/a
17. The Sklar Brothers (1) - 66 pts. n/a
18. John Mulaney - 65 pts. n/a
19. Demetri Martin - 60 pts. t19
t20. Andy Daly (1) - 57 pts. n/a
t20. David Cross (1) - 57 pts. t17
Note that of the Grammy nominees, only the Conchords made this list. Paul F. Thomkins, is best known as the guy who introduces Tenacious D at open mike gigs. Obviously the dude isn’t part of the A list yet, but he’s tops in the comedy underground.
Hopefully in 2008 we’ll see new albums from Dave Attell, Lewis Black, and David Cross.
(more…)